James was last seen leaving the "Hideaway Club' at approximately 3:15am in the company of five individuals all of whom have been reported missing as well. All six individuals were traveling in a burgundy 1986 Chevrolet Caprice. The other individuals were found inside a car submerged in the Pea River in Coffee County, Alabama on September 29, 1999. Mr. Reynolds body was never recovered. Despite numerous searches of the river only a dark colored jacket believed to belong to Reynolds has been found. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Covering or sharing this case? Use the tools below to help keep the flyer visible while staying connected to source information.
If you are covering this case in a video, podcast, article, or social post, please keep the focus on verified details and direct viewers to the listed agency with any information.
QR codeQR-code options are available inside the shareable flyer builder.
Before sharing:
Check the source.
Do not post tips publicly.
Do not share rumors or theories.
Send information directly to law enforcement or the listed agency.
Update or remove posts if the case status changes.