Allen Carl Warner

The Cape May County Prosecutor’s Office is investigating the August 28, 1973 disappearance of Allen Carl Warner. Mr. Warner was last seen by members of the North Wildwood Police Department on August 27, 1973. At the time of the disappearance, Mr. Warner was described as being a 21-year-old white male standing 6’2” and weighing 185 pounds and having blonde hair and blue eyes. On August 28, 1973, a boat belonging to Mr. Warner’s father was found adrift two miles off the Atlantic coast of Cape May County. Located within the boat were the personal effects and identification of Mr. Warner. Several days prior to his disappearance Mr. Warner stated to family members that if he ever got into trouble with law enforcement he “would leave and not face it.” Mr. Warner has not been seen or heard from since August 27, 1973 and his remains have never been found. Anyone with information about the circumstances surrounding the disappearance of Allen Carl Warner or his current whereabouts is requested to contact the Cape May County Prosecutor’s Office Major Crimes Unit at 609-465-1135 or can leave anonymous information on the tip line at 609-463-LEAD (5323)..

CaseTrace is not an emergency reporting system. If someone is in immediate danger, call 911. For official tips or urgent case information, contact the investigating agency directly.

CaseTrace is for awareness and responsible information sharing only. Do not approach, confront, follow, accuse, or investigate anyone based on case information. Submit credible information through the proper tip channel or contact the investigating agency directly. If someone is in immediate danger, call 911.

Submitted tips are not displayed publicly. They are intended for authorized review only.

Helpful tips include where, when, what you saw, vehicle details, direction of travel, photos, or other specific facts. Avoid guesses, rumors, or accusations.

Do not submit false, harassing, threatening, or intentionally misleading information.